24/7 Emergency Response  •  Serving NYC & Long Island  •  646-543-2242

Sewage Guide

Sewer Backup in NYC: Who Pays and the 90-Day City Claim

We pump out the sewage, remove what it soaked, disinfect and dry. Then the money question: whose pipe failed, the 90-day City claim, and what insurance may cover.

★★★★★ 5.0 from 60+ Google reviewsIICRC-CertifiedNY State Mold License15+ Years of ExperienceLicensed & Insured

When sewage comes up through a floor drain or a basement toilet, All Star Restoration pumps it out, hauls away what it soaked, disinfects what stays, dries the walls and slab, and rebuilds what had to come out. Call 646-543-2242 whenever it happens. Arrival is usually 30 minutes to an hour and a half, depending on the hour and traffic.

Who pays is a second question, and the answer depends on where the pipe failed. The line from your building out to the City's main in the street is yours. If the main itself backed up and you believe the City was at fault, a notice of claim has to reach the NYC Comptroller within 90 days. This page walks through the cleanup first, then whose pipe it was, the City claim and insurance.

What we do when sewage backs up

Sewage cleanup is a removal and drying job, and a mop does not do it. On a backup call our crew works in this order:

  • Photograph first. Every room, the drains, the boiler area and the mark the sewage left on the walls, before anything is moved.
  • Get the sewage out. Pumps and extractors, with the crew in protective gear.
  • Remove what it soaked. Carpet, pad, drywall, insulation and stored contents that can't be cleaned get bagged and carried out.
  • Disinfect what stays. Concrete, brick and framing are cleaned and then treated with antimicrobial.
  • Dry it and prove it. Air movers and dehumidifiers run while we log moisture readings on each visit, usually daily, and they stay until those numbers come back dry.
  • Rebuild. Our own crew puts the walls and floors back, and the repairs stay with the company that did the tear-out.

We aren't plumbers. A licensed plumber clears or repairs the pipe, and we take the sewage, the cleanup and the rebuild. If the drain is still backing up when we get there, the plumber goes first or works next to us. Each step is laid out in more detail in how we clean up after a sewage backup.

Crew member in an All Star shirt placing blue air movers down a narrow hallway
Air movers go down once the sewage and soaked materials are out.

Who pays for a sewer backup in NYC?

It depends on whose pipe failed. In New York City the property owner is responsible for maintaining and repairing the sewer service line that connects the building to the City's sewer main, and the main is the City's. NYC DEP spells out the split on its sewer backup page: when the problem is traced to your line you are issued a Notice to Repair, and when DEP confirms a backup in the City's system it starts the repair.

It's easy to assume the City pays because the sewer is the City's. But the pipe under your front yard and sidewalk, out to the main, belongs to you. DEP also says the most common cause of sewer backups in New York City is blocked pipes, from grease, wipes and other things sent down toilets and sinks. A clog like that can sit in your line or in the main, which is why the inspection matters.

What failedWho fixes itWhere the damage money may come fromYour move
Your sewer service line or house trapYou, with a licensed plumber. DEP issues a Notice to Repair.Your own policy, if it has water backup coverage. DEP says the line repair could be covered by homeowners insurance or its Service Line Protection Program, if you're enrolled.Get a plumber on the line and start cleanup.
The City's sewer mainDEP starts the repair once it confirms the backup.A claim with the NYC Comptroller, if you believe the City was at fault, plus your own policy if it covers backups.Keep the 311 and CSR# numbers. Serve the notice of claim within 90 days.
Not confirmed either wayDEP may flush the system.Open until the source is known.Keep the 311 number and have a plumber run a camera through your line.

Your line or the City's main

You usually can't be sure until DEP inspects. DEP says it will inspect the location within six hours of receiving the 311 complaint, and notes that bad weather can delay inspections. If it can't confirm where the backup started, it may flush the system.

There are clues before the inspector arrives. If several houses on the block are backing up at once, the main is the likelier suspect. If it's only your house, and the lowest drain overflows when someone runs water upstairs, look at your own line and the house trap first. A licensed plumber can open the trap and run a camera down the line, and that recording is worth saving. Some cases aren't a backup at all: sewage in a basement or cellar sometimes comes from a cracked drain pipe inside the building, and that pipe is the owner's too.

Sewage pouring out of an open drain pipe against the stone foundation wall of a basement
A drain line letting go inside a basement. Pipes on your side of the main are yours to repair.

Call 311 and keep every number

Report the backup to 311 by phone or through the 311 website as soon as you see it. Give accurate contact information, because DEP says it can't investigate a complaint without it. Write down the 311 tracking number, which begins with 311-, and the DEP Customer Service Request number (CSR#) if you get one. The City's claim form asks if you reported the incident, on what date, and for the complaint number.

Safety comes before photos. Stay out of standing sewage if it is near outlets, the electric panel or a running appliance, and keep children and pets upstairs. If you do go down, wear rubber boots and gloves, and stop running water in the house so no more comes up the drain.

Then, from where it is safe to stand, shoot your own pictures before a single thing is moved: a wide shot of each room, the line left on the walls, the floor drain, the boiler and water heater, stored boxes, and anything in a basement apartment. Close-ups of damaged items help later, when someone has to list them one by one.

The 90-day notice of claim

If you believe the City was at fault, DEP tells owners to contact the NYC Comptroller's Office within 90 days. The Comptroller's File a Claim page cites state law, General Municipal Law §50-e: a notice of claim "must be properly served within 90 days from the date of occurrence." The office accepts three ways of serving it: electronically through its eClaim system, by personal delivery, or by registered or certified mail. Its property damage FAQ adds that notices of claim cannot be filed by email, and says to use the Water Damage Claim Form when a claim involves a sewer backup. A backup from the main is not an automatic payment. The office investigates first, and its FAQ says it may offer a settlement if the City may be legally liable.

The paper version, titled Water Damage or Loss Claim Form, has to be notarized. There is a second clock too. The same FAQ says lawsuits must be filed in court within 1 year and 90 days of the incident, and that the office cannot settle a claim after that. Whether to sue, and when, is for a lawyer to answer, not a restoration company. For filing questions the Comptroller lists its Community Action Center at (212) 669-3916.

Read the form before cleanup starts, because it shows what the City will ask:

  • A list of the damaged articles, and whether you have photos of the damage
  • Whether you reported it to DEP, the date, and the complaint number
  • How the water entered, with choices that include the trap, toilet, sink, bathtub and foundation walls
  • The highest water level, how long it was there, and how it was removed
  • A description of any structural damage
  • Your insurance company and the amount it paid

We don't file the claim, and no restoration company can tell you whether the City will pay. What we do is hand you our photos and the moisture readings we log on each visit, usually daily, which speak to the water level, removal and structural lines on that list. Here is what goes into our job file.

Does insurance cover sewer backup?

Sometimes. It depends on the policy. New York's Department of Financial Services says a homeowners or renters policy may cover water backup and sewage damage, for example by an endorsement added to the policy. So look for a water backup or sewer backup endorsement on your declarations page before you assume anything, and ask your agent or adjuster how it applies. They have the final word, not us.

The pipe repair is a separate bill from the cleanup. DEP says repairs to a private sewer service line could be covered under your homeowners insurance or its Service Line Protection Program, if you are enrolled.

In a two-family with a basement apartment, the owner's policy and the tenant's renters policy are separate things, so photograph the tenant's rooms and belongings as well.

If you rent, cleaning up the sewage and repairing the building is generally the owner's job. Tell the landlord or super in writing as soon as you see the backup. Your own furniture and belongings are a matter for your renters policy, if you carry one.

Cleanup does not wait for the claim

A lot of owners hold off until DEP, the City or the adjuster signs off. We think that's backwards. DEP itself says it is important to thoroughly clean and disinfect inside your home after a sewer backup, and warns that direct exposure may infect your eyes, skin, stomach or intestines.

Waiting doesn't protect a claim. It grows the damage you're trying to recover. Sewage is Category 3 water, the most contaminated grade there is, and drywall, insulation and wood floors keep drawing it upward the longer it sits. Our guide on what makes raw sewage a health hazard covers the reasons.

That DFS page also says property owners are responsible for protecting their property from further damage after a loss, and that permanent repairs should not be made until the insurer has inspected. In practice: photograph everything, tell your insurer the same day, ask what they want kept, and let the sewage and soaked materials come out. The rebuild holds until the adjuster has seen the loss.

Before you hang up with anyone

Call 311 and save the tracking number. Photograph every room and every damaged item. Ask your adjuster what to keep. Get a plumber on the line, then call 646-543-2242 about the sewage, and mark the calendar 90 days from the day of the backup. Who pays comes down to whose pipe failed, what your policy says, and whether that notice went in on time.

Sewage on the basement floor right now

All Star pumps out, disinfects and dries sewer backups in all five boroughs and Nassau County, 24 hours a day.

Call 646-543-2242Sewer Backup Cleanup

Questions

Sewer backup questions

Who is responsible for a sewer backup in NYC?

The property owner is responsible for the sewer service line that runs from the building to the City's main, and the City is responsible for the main. If DEP traces the problem to your line, it issues a Notice to Repair. If it confirms a backup in the City's system, DEP starts the repair.

How long do I have to file a sewer backup claim with the City?

The NYC Comptroller says a notice of claim must be served within 90 days from the date of occurrence. Its property damage FAQ also says a lawsuit must be filed in court within 1 year and 90 days of the incident. Ask a lawyer about that second deadline.

Do I need a DEP complaint number to file a claim?

The Comptroller's water damage form asks if you reported the incident to DEP, on what date, and for the complaint number. Call 311 when the backup happens and keep the tracking number and any CSR# you are given.

Does All Star file the City claim for me?

No. The notice of claim is yours to file, and the decision to sue belongs with a lawyer. We give you our photos and the moisture readings we log on each visit, usually daily, so you have them for the City and for your insurer.

Can I clean up a sewage backup myself?

We don't recommend it. Sewage is Category 3 water, and DEP warns that direct exposure may infect your eyes, skin, stomach or intestines. Soaked drywall, carpet and insulation usually have to come out, and what stays has to be disinfected and dried until a meter confirms it.

Should I wait for the adjuster before cleanup starts?

Usually no. Photograph everything, call your insurer the same day, and ask what they want kept. Then get the sewage and the soaked materials out. The rebuild is the part that waits for the adjuster.

Keep Reading

More guides

Request Service

Tell us what happened

We'll call you right back, and give you a free estimate. For an active emergency, the fastest way to reach us is by phone, day or night.

24/7 Emergency Line
646-543-2242

By submitting, you agree to be contacted by All Star Restoration by phone, text, or email about your request.

Call NowRequest Service